Hall County School District 40-0082 v. Sackschewsky

Case Number(s)
S-25-0750
Case Audio
Call Date
Case Time
Court Number
Hall
Case Location
Blair
Court Type
District Court
Case Summary

S-25-0750 Hall County School District 40-0082, a/k/a Northwest Public Schools (Appellant) v. David S. Sackschewsky (Appellee) 

Appeal from the District Court for Hall County, Judge Andrew C. Butler 

Attorneys: Justin J. Knight (Perry, Guthery, Haase & Gessford, P.C., L.L.O. for Appellant) and Mark Porto (Wolf, McDermott, Depue, Sabott, Butz, Porto Fowles, LLC for Appellee)  

Civil: Statute of limitations, equitable estoppel, and equitable tolling 

Proceedings below:  Appellant filed a complaint for fraud, conversion, embezzlement, breach of fiduciary duties, and unjust enrichment against Appellee, who was a former employee of Appellant.  Appellee filed a motion to dismiss based on a statute of limitations defense, which the district court granted.  On its own motion, the Nebraska Supreme Court ordered this case to be transferred from the docket of the Nebraska Court of Appeals to its docket.    

Issues:  Appellant assigns the following errors:  1) The district court erred in determining amendment would be futile and therefore dismissing Appellant’s complaint with prejudice; 2) The district court erred in failing to accept Appellant’s factual allegations in the complaint as true and failing to draw all reasonable inferences in Appellant’s favor; 3) The district court erred in determining that Appellant’s reliance on the 2019 sentencing order was not reasonable and therefore refusing to apply the doctrine of equitable estoppel; and 4) The district court erred in failing to equitably toll the statute of limitations while Appellee was making restitution payments. 

Extended Case Summary

S-25-0750 Hall County School District 40-0082, a/k/a Northwest Public Schools (Appellant) v. David S. Sackschewsky (Appellee) 

Appeal from the District Court for Hall County, Judge Andrew C. Butler 

Attorneys: Justin J. Knight (Perry, Guthery, Haase & Gessford, P.C., L.L.O. for Appellant) and Mark Porto (Wolf, McDermott, Depue, Sabott, Butz, Porto Fowles, LLC for Appellee)  

David Sackschewsky was previously employed as a music teacher for Northwest Public Schools.  While employed, Sackschewsky improperly made ATM withdrawals from the school’s bank account, improperly made checks payable to himself, and wrongfully took booster club money.  In 2019, Sackschewsky was convicted of crimes arising out of this behavior, and he was placed on probation.  Part of his probation required him to pay restitution to the school district in the amount of $150,000.00.  The sentencing court determined that he was financially able to pay this amount, and it ordered him to pay $1,700.00 a month for sixty (60) months.  He made those payments from 2019 until late November 2024, and he then stopped making the payments.   

In 2025, the school district sued Sackschewsky for fraud, conversion, embezzlement, breach of fiduciary duties, and unjust enrichment.  These are all legal theories under which the school district alleged that Sackschewsky was required to pay back all the money that was taken.  In response, Sackschewsky alleged that the statute of limitations had run, and he asked the district court to dismiss the lawsuit.  A statute of limitations is a law that gives a party a limited period of time in which to bring a lawsuit.  A failure to bring suit within the timeframe identified in statute of limitations requires the case to be dismissed as time barred.  The district court agreed with Sackschewsky and determined that the suit was time-barred, and it dismissed the lawsuit.  The school district appeals.  On its own motion, the Nebraska Supreme Court removed this case from the docket of the Nebraska Court of Appeals and transferred this case to its docket.   

On appeal, the school district argues that the lawsuit against Sackschewsky should not have been dismissed.  Because the lawsuit was dismissed prior to trial, the school district argues that the allegations it made against Sackschewsky should have been assumed to be true and that the district court failed to do this.  It also argues that the district court erred when it determined that amending its lawsuit would be pointless.  The school district also argues that equity (or fairness) required the district court to toll, or to pause, the statute of limitations during the time that Sackschewsky was on probation because of the partial payments that he made.  The parties have filed briefs with the Nebraska Supreme Court, and the case is now ready for oral argument.  Each party will have ten minutes to argue their case before the Nebraska Supreme Court and to answer questions. 

Schedule Code
SC