A-25-0725, Hills Brothers Intermodal Logistics, Inc. (Appellee) v. MTG Trucking, L.L.C. (Appellant)
Douglas County District Court, Judge Katie L. Benson
Attorney for Appellant: Perry A. Pirsch (Pirsche Legal Services, PC, LLO)
Attorney for Appellee: Amit Mukherjee (Fraser Stryker PC LLO)
Civil: summary judgment; directed verdict; breach of contract; indemnity; Carmack Amendment; due process; motion for interpreter
Action Taken by Trial Court: The district court denied the Appellant’s motions for summary judgment and for an interpreter. During trial, the court denied both the Appellant and Appellee’s motions for directed verdict. Following trial, the jury returned a verdict in favor of the Appellee, finding the Appellant liable for Appellee’s Carmack Amendment claims and its state law breach of contract claim. The jury awarded the Appellee $33,378.48 in damages, and the district court entered a judgment on the verdict.
Assignments of Error on Appeal: On appeal, Appellant asserts that the district court erred in: (1) denying it’s motion for an interpreter; (2) denying it’s motion for summary judgment on Appellee’s cause of action under the Carmack Amendment and Appellee’s state law breach of contract claim; (3) denying it’s motion for directed verdict; and (4) permitting the jury to consider state law claims of breach of contract in violation of preemption under the Carmack Amendment. Appellant further assigns that (5) it was entitled to judgment as a matter of law on its counterclaim for breach of contract.